- All Agarwood products
- Other Fragrant Wood Products
- About Us
- Contact Us
- Agarwood Related Articles
On Black Friday, you went online marketplace and found some oud (agarwood oil) with a "good" price because it was on special. You pulled out the credit card and checked out.
Two weeks later, you received the parcel in the mailbox. With excitement, you ripped the box open, having your oil presented in front of you.
Gently opened your cap, took a small dab on your wrist, smelled it and...
You felt something was not right. After trying several times, you became more suspicious. All you want would be the answer if this oud were 100% pure.
Frustrated, you contacted the seller, questioned him/her about the product. Being Friday afternoon, it meant the seller might not answer you until Monday.
Two days passed, you finally received an answer from the seller: "Hi, it was pure oud oil". That is? Without further explanation.
You wrote back and asked if the seller has any proof because something was not right. Let's supposed the seller has a lab test report, you need to learn what to look for.
However, how would you know if the report was for this particular oil that you purchased? It was out of your control.
With a large purchase, a big company would perform their testing. It made sense to spend a few hundred to verify the oil content as the investment could be five or 6-figure worth. But what if you only pay around one hundred for a bottle of oud oil, the test would cost more than the oil itself. Besides, the lab needs a minimum of 3ml; some even asked for 5ml to start with. So, it might not be a good option for some of you.
How are you going to get an answer without spending hundred of dollars in GCMS, or lab test?
Don't worry; you can perform a small test at home by just using water
Before we continue, I would like to let you know what is this test NOT FOR
What is for?
I will explain why
When I was in grade 6 middle school, and in chemistry class, my teacher demonstrated an experience about density
He explained some physical properties of water and he asked all of us followed him to a bigger classroom.
In that room, he brought out a rectangular tank, just like a fish tank. In that tank, it was half-filled with water.
He got a different glass container. Inside that container was a red liquid
So I just introduced the principle how it works
In the below example, I will do this test for six different samples and show you the results.
What you need:
Make sure the cap is tight before you start shaking.
How long? 5 to 10 seconds will do.
The magic happens here. When you shake, the oil breaks down into smaller droplets. Let it rest for 10 minutes. Once settled, you start observing. Below are the possible outcomes.
Essential oil floats because it is lighter than water (one of the exceptions was clove essential oil, which sinks because it is denser than water)
See the below oud oil in water distillation. The oil floats
After 15 minutes, all the droplets would gather on the top. The solution returned clear.
Look closely to see if there were any separate layers. If not, it was likely that there was only one essential oil in the sample.
Disclosure: This is our oud "Smooth Oud."
There are four interesting parts of this example.
Each case is different, but from the above image, although I am unable to identify what exactly was inside this bottle, the sample is NOT pure essential oil. Here are the reasons
Conclusion: This sample is NOT pure oud although there is some oud in the mixture.
The product description was "natural oud perfume". The solution was clear; this is consistent with the product label "contains fractionated coconut oil" which is water-soluble.
This sample smells like oud; there were two different oils here. One maybe oud, the second one was the cloudy stuff that was circled in red which may be a "trade secret sauce" (joking, I don't know what it was).
This sample contains more than one oil, so this vendor is not right when claiming this product is 100% pure oud oil.
This case is an easy one; essential oil does not mix with water. This oil was claimed as "oud perfume oil" which is true. It does smell oud, rose and citrus.
The solution was cloudy because of the presence of the non-toxic, water-soluble Dipropylene Glycol (DPG). The oil-based perfumes contain this as a solvent.
This sample is Oud oil from CO2 supercritical extract. Before doing this experiment, I guessed this CO2 oud oil would sink because 1 ml of this oud is 1.03g, which is denser than water. Isn't it interesting when "extracting" the same material - "pulverised agarwood"- one oil floats and the other one sinks?
Take ginger, for example, ginger essential oil and ginger CO2 extract oil are both floats above the water.
Ginger Co2 extract
Being denser the water, it would sink. To dive deeper, I asked Dr WS, known as Kyarazen (I am a fan of his work). He messaged me which I was so grateful "Oleoresins have different lengths. Generally older materials, then oleoresin would tend to sink. In steam or hydrodistillation, you get most of the volatiles or short-chain stuff. CO2 can pull out the longer stuff, especially at supercritical."
To show you a comparison, I put it next to the cloudy number 5 (the oud oil perfume contains so water-soluble DPG)
1) Oud oil: this our oud to begin with :)
2) Claimed as pure oud oil: but it was not, there was more than one essential oil
3) Perfume Oud Oil with fractionated coconut oil:
4) Claimed as Pure Oud oil: this one got cloudy stuff on the surface, there was at least two different oil, so no, this is not pure oud. If you have this experience, contact seller
5) Perfume with DPG: DPG is water-soluble hence the cloudy solution
6) Agarwood oil, CO2 extract: as above, this contains longer-chain which is denser than water, it sinks. You can see some are above the water, according to Kyarazen, these are from shorter chain
So I decided to get one old attar which I no longer used and pour some into the water. This experiment reminds me of the good old-time in class " the water vs oil experiment in high school."
I was not going to deep here as I did not know what contained in this attar exactly. I could detect pepper, citrus and "something familiar."
It had four layers after 2 hours.
So, next time, when in doubt, try this test.
Please note, this is not the test for 100% pure oud oil. This method is simply a test if there is any additional substance in a solution apart from essential oil.
When using an essential oil, if the label claimed it was pure, and you felt it was not from experience, do this little test to find out.
If the bottle contains an essential oil only, you will see a consistent layer. If the oil is denser than water, all the oil should be at the bottle of the test bottle or vial when you add water.
If you see something floats while others sink, it means that the solution is inconsistent. It contains more than one essential oil or more than one substance.
(Source: self-taken, the essential oil is floating up, the pink bottom pearls are synthetic vanilla)
Comments will be approved before showing up.
by Trent Tran June 10, 2021 4 min readRead More
by Trent Tran April 17, 2021 7 min readRead More